Skip to content
Creatisimo

Can I use AI to extend a photo background for a different crop ratio

Asked by Nina W. · AI in design workflows1 replyupdated

Short answer

At our studio the rule is simple: the original frame stays untouched, the extension lives on its own layer, and the client sees both. Nobody has ever been upset about an extended wall. People get upset when they find out later without being told. A one line note in the delivery email, "background extended for banner format", covers it.

From the top reply by Arlo P. ·
CiteCreatisimo, "Can I use AI to extend a photo background for a different crop ratio", https://creatisimo.net/topic/can-i-use-ai-to-extend-a-photo-background-for-a-different-crop-ratio/, accessed 2026-11-18.
  1. Member ·

    A client booked me for headshots and shot them tight, which is how they asked. Now their marketing person wants the same frames as a wide banner and as a tall story format. The background in the original is a plain wall with a soft gradient, so I tried Generative Expand in Photoshop to extend it. The result looks clean to me.

    What bothers me is the line between retouching and manipulation. I never touch the person beyond normal edits, but I am adding pixels that were not photographed. Do I need to tell the client? Does the export get marked as AI because of it? And should I deliver the extended files at all, or tell them to reshoot wider?

    I have been fighting the idea that my work looks "fake" since clients started asking whether everything is AI now, so I do not want to hide a step and have it come back to bite me.

    0
    ReplyLink

Plain text or simple Markdown. Links are nofollow. Your email is never shown.

  1. Arlo P.Member ·

    At our studio the rule is simple: the original frame stays untouched, the extension lives on its own layer, and the client sees both. Nobody has ever been upset about an extended wall. People get upset when they find out later without being told. A one line note in the delivery email, "background extended for banner format", covers it.