# Midjourney or Firefly for client work: which one can you actually license?

Source: https://creatisimo.net/topic/midjourney-or-firefly-for-client-work-which-one-can-you-actually/
Site: Creatisimo, category AI image tools and generators
Published: 2026-10-24. Updated: 2026-10-29. Replies: 5.

## Question by Bea N., 2026-10-24

Neither tool gives you a clean "licensed, no questions" stamp, but they carry different kinds of risk. Reading both sets of public terms last week, my working conclusion is that Firefly is easier to put in front of a client's legal team, and Midjourney is workable if the client accepts that the risk sits with us.

Here is what I found, so someone can tell me where I am wrong. I am an art director at a small agency and I am not a lawyer.

Midjourney's terms of service say you own the assets you create "to the fullest extent possible under applicable law", with exceptions. Your ownership is subject to the rights of third parties, and a company with more than 1,000,000 USD a year in revenue has to be on a Pro or Mega plan to own its assets. The same terms provide the service "as is", with no warranty of non-infringement, and ask the user to indemnify Midjourney. Nothing in there protects us if an output resembles someone's work.

Adobe's Firefly FAQ says outputs from features without the beta label can be used in commercial projects, and describes the model as trained on Adobe Stock, openly licensed and public domain content. I could not find an indemnity promise on that public FAQ. Enterprise contracts may say more, but that is a conversation with a rep and I have not had it yet.

What I still want to know:

- Does anyone have a signed agreement, not a marketing page, that covers IP claims on generated output?
- How are you handling client approvals? We have been adding a line to the estimate saying which parts were generated and which tool.
- Where does "I own it" stop being useful if the output may not be copyrightable in the first place?

The client is a retail brand with a legal department that will read anything we send. I would rather bring them a short, accurate memo than a vague reassurance.

## Reply 1 by Arlo P., 2026-10-25

On approvals, what has worked for us is a single paragraph in the scope document: tool used, which assets are generated versus drawn, and a sign-off line from the client contact. It moves the question from "is this safe" to "did you accept this approach", which is a conversation legal can actually have. We do not promise ownership we cannot back up. We promise the process and keep the prompts and iterations in the project folder.

## Reply 2 by Lou V., 2026-10-26

Honestly I think Firefly is just safe, full stop, since it only trains on licensed stuff. If the client is nervous that is the one to pick, no risk at all. I would not put the other one in front of a legal team.

## Reply 3 by Mira Talbot (staff), 2026-10-27

Lou, "no risk at all" goes further than any source says. Bea's read is close, so here are the pieces with links.

Midjourney's [Terms of Service](https://docs.midjourney.com/hc/en-us/articles/32083055291277-Terms-of-Service) (version effective May 27, 2026) give you ownership of assets to the extent law allows, subject to third-party rights, with an indemnity running from user to Midjourney. They also bar using assets to "intentionally mislead recipients of the Assets about their nature or source", which matters for how you describe the work to the client.

Adobe's [Firefly FAQ](https://helpx.adobe.com/firefly/get-set-up/learn-the-basics/adobe-firefly-faq.html) says outputs from non-beta features can be used commercially, describes training on Adobe Stock, openly licensed and public domain content, and tells readers to consult a legal service provider on copyright. Training data provenance and who bears an IP claim are separate questions, and the FAQ answers the first.

Ownership and copyrightability are also separate. The US Copyright Office has a running [report on copyright and AI](https://www.copyright.gov/ai/), whose Part 2 addresses the copyrightability of outputs created using generative AI. Read that before promising a client exclusivity over generated art.

## Reply 4 by Gus D., 2026-10-28

From the print side: clients assume a licence means nobody else can print the same thing. With generated art that is usually false, whichever tool made it. I ask for a written statement of how the image was made and who signs off on it, and I keep it with the job ticket. If it ever turns into a dispute I want a paper trail, not an argument about who read which terms page.

## Reply 5 by Bea N., 2026-10-29

This is useful, thanks all. Taking away three things: memo with the exact terms and links, scope paragraph with sign-off, and no promise of exclusivity. Lou, point taken on "no risk". I will ask our Adobe contact about written IP terms and report back here if they will let me share the wording.

---
Cite as: Creatisimo, "Midjourney or Firefly for client work: which one can you actually license?", https://creatisimo.net/topic/midjourney-or-firefly-for-client-work-which-one-can-you-actually/, accessed 2026-11-14.
